New Age Medical Aesthetics & Plastic Surgery vs Dr. Brett Beber: which fits your case?
Both clinics are genuine alternatives for anyone shortlisting a Plastic Surgery Clinic in Ontario, and both score within a point of each other under our methodology. The real choice comes down to what you're having done and how much hand-holding you want along the way, not the headline score.
Verdict
This comes down to fit, not the score, since the two sit a single point apart. Someone who wants OHIP-eligible coverage, facial surgery on the menu, and a slow, no-pressure consult should lean toward New Age Medical Aesthetics & Plastic Surgery. Someone with a medically complex case, surgical anxiety, or a preference for a longer-tenured surgeon with academic ties should lean toward Dr. Brett Beber.
Which should you pick?
Pick New Age Medical Aesthetics & Plastic Surgery if
- You want a procedure that's OHIP-eligible
- You're after facial surgery or laser/injectable rejuvenation alongside surgical work
- You want a slow, no-pressure consult process and check-ins that continue for months after
Pick Dr. Brett Beber - Toronto Plastic Surgeon if
- You have a medically complex case or surgical anxiety and want extra reassurance
- You value a surgeon with a long track record and academic (U of T) affiliation
- You're focused on breast surgery or body contouring with an emphasis on minimal scarring
The differences that matter
- OHIP-covered procedures. New Age Medical Aesthetics accepts OHIP patients for some procedures, while Dr. Beber's practice profile makes no mention of OHIP coverage.
- Surgical scope. New Age Medical Aesthetics covers facial surgery, breast work, body contouring, and laser rejuvenation, while Dr. Beber's practice centers on breast surgery, body contouring, and injectables.
- Fit for anxious or complex cases. Dr. Beber's reviews specifically call out patients with medical complexities or surgical anxiety feeling reassured by his patience and on-site nurse support for complications, a pattern not mentioned in New Age's feedback.
- Aftercare rhythm. New Age Medical Aesthetics is noted for post-op check-ins that continue months after treatment, while Dr. Beber's team is praised for responsive, on-site nurse support if complications come up.
- Surgeon track record. Dr. Beber brings over 18 years in practice and a University of Toronto lecturer affiliation, a credential not called out in New Age's profile.
Side by side
- Google rating
- New Age Medical Aesthetics & Plastic Surgery: 4.9 (199 reviews)
- Dr. Brett Beber - Toronto Plastic Surgeon: 4.9 (159 reviews)
- Services
- New Age Medical Aesthetics & Plastic Surgery: breast augmentation, body contouring, plastic surgery clinic, facial plastic surgery
- Dr. Brett Beber - Toronto Plastic Surgeon: non surgical cosmetic, plastic surgery clinic, reconstructive surgery, gender affirming surgery
- Best for temperament
- New Age Medical Aesthetics & Plastic Surgery: Patients who want a no-pressure, goal-led consultation process
- Dr. Brett Beber - Toronto Plastic Surgeon: Patients with surgical anxiety or medical complexity who want extra reassurance
- Named injector specialist
- New Age Medical Aesthetics & Plastic Surgery: Nurse Courtney: injectables, IPL, microneedling, Botox
- Dr. Brett Beber - Toronto Plastic Surgeon: Nurse Madison: gentle, natural-looking cosmetic injections
- Specialties
- New Age Medical Aesthetics & Plastic Surgery: Facial surgery, breast work, body contouring, laser rejuvenation
- Dr. Brett Beber - Toronto Plastic Surgeon: Breast surgery, body contouring, injectables
- Verification
- New Age Medical Aesthetics & Plastic Surgery: Google-verified
- Dr. Brett Beber - Toronto Plastic Surgeon: Google-verified
- Composite score
- New Age Medical Aesthetics & Plastic Surgery: 92
- Dr. Brett Beber - Toronto Plastic Surgeon: 91
Within 3 points of each other, so treat them as effectively tied on overall quality. The choice below is about fit, not the score.
What reviewers say
New Age Medical Aesthetics & Plastic Surgery
Dr. MacArthur and his team deliver surgical and non-surgical results that consistently exceed expectations, backed by genuine follow-up care that extends months after treatment. Nurse Courtney's expertise in injectables and laser treatments, combined with personalized skincare planning and zero-pressure consultations, makes this clinic stand out for people wanting to feel heard and informed, not rushed.
The clinic accepts OHIP patients for some procedures and operates across facial surgery, breast work, body contouring, and laser rejuvenation. Staff names surface repeatedly in praise: Dr. Ian MacArthur for surgery and chin work, and Courtney for non-surgical treatments, IPL, microneedling, and Botox. Reviewers consistently note that post-op check-ins happen months later.
Dr. Brett Beber - Toronto Plastic Surgeon
Dr. Beber's patients consistently report feeling heard and cared for from consultation through recovery. Reviewers praise his surgical precision, gentle demeanor, and team support, with many noting minimal scarring, quick healing, and results that exceed expectations.
His scope spans breast surgery, body contouring, and injectables. Nurse Madison receives repeated praise for skilful, gentle injections and natural-looking cosmetic outcomes. Patients with medical complexities or surgical anxiety report feeling especially reassured by his patience and the clinic's responsive aftercare.
Need help deciding?
Describe what you're looking for and get responses from plastic surgeon in Ontario offering consultations in your region.
Enquiries submitted through our contact forms may be shared with partner providers who can do the work, and we may receive a referral fee. Our rankings and scores are based on our published method only, separate from any referral fees we earn.
FAQ
- Which clinic accepts OHIP?
- New Age Medical Aesthetics & Plastic Surgery accepts OHIP patients for some procedures; this isn't mentioned in Dr. Beber's practice profile.
- Which is better for someone nervous about surgery?
- Dr. Beber's reviews repeatedly note patients with surgical anxiety or medical complexities feeling reassured by his patience and the team's on-site nurse support for complications.
- Do both offer facial surgery?
- New Age Medical Aesthetics lists facial surgery as part of its scope; Dr. Beber's profile centers on breast surgery, body contouring, and injectables without mentioning facial surgery.
- Who has the named injector specialists?
- New Age Medical Aesthetics has Nurse Courtney for injectables, IPL, microneedling, and Botox; Dr. Beber's practice has Nurse Madison for cosmetic injections.