New Age Medical Aesthetics vs McRae Plastic Surgery for gender-affirming surgery
New Age Medical Aesthetics & Plastic Surgery and McRae Plastic Surgery are both realistic options in Ontario for someone researching gender-affirming surgery, but they come from different starting points: one is a clinic built around a surgeon-plus-injector team with OHIP intake for some procedures, the other is a hospital-based surgical practice with twin board-certified surgeons. This comparison follows our methodology and focuses on what actually matters when you're picking a surgical team for this specific procedure.
Verdict
The deciding factor here isn't the score gap, which is nearly a tie: it's whether your case needs hospital-based reconstructive expertise or a clinic pathway that folds OHIP coverage and non-surgical care into one team. McRae Plastic Surgery fits patients weighing revision or more complex reconstructive work who want a hospital setting and a highly responsive coordinator. New Age Medical Aesthetics & Plastic Surgery fits patients for whom OHIP intake and a combined surgical-plus-injectables relationship, with long-running post-op check-ins, is the priority.
Which should you pick?
Pick New Age Medical Aesthetics & Plastic Surgery if
- OHIP funding for your procedure matters and you want a clinic that already processes OHIP patients
- You want non-surgical or adjunct care (laser, injectables, skincare planning) folded into the same practice as your surgery
- You want a low-pressure consultation process with check-ins that continue for months after treatment
Pick McRae Plastic Surgery if
- You're considering a revision or reconstructive procedure and want a team with a specific track record there
- You'd rather be treated within a hospital setting (Saint Michael's Hospital) than a private clinic
- You want a highly responsive point of contact (Lacey) plus a surgeon who reportedly follows up personally, even after hours
The differences that matter
- OHIP coverage. New Age Medical Aesthetics states it accepts OHIP patients for some procedures, which matters directly for OHIP-funded gender-affirming surgery, while nothing in McRae's record mentions OHIP intake.
- Surgical setting. McRae operates out of Saint Michael's Hospital in Toronto with a Burlington follow-up location, a hospital-based setup, whereas New Age runs as a dedicated aesthetics and plastic surgery clinic.
- Reconstructive and revision track record. McRae's review record specifically calls out reconstructive procedures and revisional surgery with patients reporting better results than their first surgery elsewhere, a data point New Age's summary doesn't touch.
- Surgical plus non-surgical pathway. New Age pairs Dr. MacArthur's surgical work with Nurse Courtney's injectables, laser, and skincare planning under one roof, while McRae's praise centers on the surgical team (Dr. Mark and Dr. Matthew McRae) and coordinator Lacey rather than adjunct non-surgical care.
- Follow-up style. New Age is noted for check-ins that continue months after treatment in a low-pressure clinic setting, while McRae's surgeon reportedly follows up personally, including after-hours contact, backed by a highly responsive patient coordinator.
Side by side
- Google rating
- New Age Medical Aesthetics & Plastic Surgery: 4.9 (199 reviews)
- McRae Plastic Surgery: 5 (117 reviews)
- Services
- New Age Medical Aesthetics & Plastic Surgery: breast augmentation, body contouring, plastic surgery clinic, facial plastic surgery
- McRae Plastic Surgery: non surgical cosmetic, plastic surgery clinic, reconstructive surgery, gender affirming surgery
- OHIP-covered procedures
- New Age Medical Aesthetics & Plastic Surgery: Accepts OHIP patients for some procedures
- McRae Plastic Surgery: Not mentioned in review record
- Surgical setting
- New Age Medical Aesthetics & Plastic Surgery: Clinic-based aesthetics and plastic surgery practice
- McRae Plastic Surgery: Hospital-based (Saint Michael's Hospital, Toronto) plus Burlington follow-up site
- Best for revision or reconstructive cases
- New Age Medical Aesthetics & Plastic Surgery: Not specifically noted
- McRae Plastic Surgery: Reviewers specifically cite reconstructive and revisional surgery outcomes
- Care team structure
- New Age Medical Aesthetics & Plastic Surgery: Surgeon (Dr. MacArthur) plus dedicated injectables/laser specialist (Courtney)
- McRae Plastic Surgery: Twin board-certified surgeons plus responsive patient coordinator (Lacey)
- Verification
- New Age Medical Aesthetics & Plastic Surgery: Google-verified
- McRae Plastic Surgery: Google-verified
- Composite score
- New Age Medical Aesthetics & Plastic Surgery: 92
- McRae Plastic Surgery: 91
Within 3 points of each other, so treat them as effectively tied on overall quality. The choice below is about fit, not the score.
What reviewers say
New Age Medical Aesthetics & Plastic Surgery
Dr. MacArthur and his team deliver surgical and non-surgical results that consistently exceed expectations, backed by genuine follow-up care that extends months after treatment. Nurse Courtney's expertise in injectables and laser treatments, combined with personalized skincare planning and zero-pressure consultations, makes this clinic stand out for people wanting to feel heard and informed, not rushed.
The clinic accepts OHIP patients for some procedures and operates across facial surgery, breast work, body contouring, and laser rejuvenation. Staff names surface repeatedly in praise: Dr. Ian MacArthur for surgery and chin work, and Courtney for non-surgical treatments, IPL, microneedling, and Botox. Reviewers consistently note that post-op check-ins happen months later.
McRae Plastic Surgery
Reviewers consistently report exceptional outcomes across breast, facial, and reconstructive procedures, with minimal scarring and natural-looking results even weeks post-op. Dr. Mark McRae and his team (including twin brother Dr. Matthew) combine surgical precision with genuine care-taking time to listen, explain procedures clearly, and follow up personally; Lacey, the patient coordinator, stands out for responsiveness to patient questions.
Patients praise the thorough consultation process, professionalism during surgery, and smooth recovery guidance. The practice operates at Saint Michael's Hospital in Toronto and a Burlington follow-up location. No complaints appear in the review record; even patients choosing revisional surgery with Dr. McRae report better outcomes than their first procedure elsewhere.
Need help deciding?
Describe what you're looking for and get responses from plastic surgeon in Ontario offering consultations in your region.
Enquiries submitted through our contact forms may be shared with partner providers who can do the work, and we may receive a referral fee. Our rankings and scores are based on our published method only, separate from any referral fees we earn.
FAQ
- Does either practice explicitly perform gender-affirming surgery?
- The review data for both practices doesn't label specific procedures as gender-affirming surgery by name. New Age's stated scope covers facial surgery, breast work, body contouring, and laser treatments; McRae's covers breast, facial, and reconstructive procedures. Confirm directly with each practice which specific gender-affirming procedures they offer.
- Which practice takes OHIP patients?
- New Age Medical Aesthetics & Plastic Surgery states it accepts OHIP patients for some procedures. There's no mention of OHIP acceptance in McRae's review record, so you'd need to ask them directly.
- Which practice has hospital access?
- McRae Plastic Surgery operates at Saint Michael's Hospital in Toronto, with a follow-up location in Burlington. New Age operates as a plastic surgery and aesthetics clinic.
- Which is better for revision surgery?
- McRae's review record specifically mentions patients who had revisional surgery with Dr. McRae reporting better outcomes than their original procedure elsewhere, which isn't a point noted in New Age's summary.