The Aesthetics Boutique vs New Age Medical Aesthetics & Plastic Surgery: which fits your facial plastic surgery needs?
Both clinics show up as strong Ontario options for facial plastic surgery, but they're built for different jobs. This comparison, based on our methodology, weighs The Aesthetics Boutique against New Age Medical Aesthetics & Plastic Surgery specifically on what matters when the work involves the face: surgical credentials, procedure scope, and aftercare.
Verdict
The real dividing line here isn't the score, it's whether "facial plastic surgery" means a scalpel or a syringe. If you need actual surgery, New Age Medical Aesthetics & Plastic Surgery is the more direct fit, with Dr. Ian MacArthur named for surgical work and OHIP accepted on some procedures. If your definition of facial plastic surgery leans non-surgical, injectables, skin treatments, and laser refinement, The Aesthetics Boutique edges ahead on both score and consistency, with Ashlynn and Charley built around honest, no-pressure consultations.
Which should you pick?
Pick The Aesthetics Boutique if
- You want non-surgical facial work, injectables, skin treatments, or laser, from a team reviewers trust to skip unnecessary upsells
- You value a long-standing relationship with named specialists and a clinic with a strong community following
- You're not seeking an actual surgical procedure on the face
Pick New Age Medical Aesthetics & Plastic Surgery if
- You need a genuine surgical procedure on the face, like chin surgery, from a board-certified surgeon
- OHIP coverage for part of the procedure would matter to you
- You want documented aftercare that continues for months following surgery
The differences that matter
- Surgeon vs. injector-led team. New Age is anchored by Dr. Ian MacArthur, a named surgeon reviewers credit for facial surgery and chin work, while The Aesthetics Boutique's praised staff, Ashlynn and Charley, are described doing injectables, skin treatments, and laser rather than surgical procedures.
- Procedure scope. New Age's stated scope covers facial surgery, breast work, and body contouring alongside laser rejuvenation, while The Aesthetics Boutique's reviews center on non-surgical refinement like injectables and skin treatments.
- Cost path for surgical work. New Age accepts OHIP for some procedures, which matters if a facial surgery is medically necessary, while no OHIP or similar coverage is mentioned for The Aesthetics Boutique.
- Post-treatment follow-up. New Age's reviewers specifically describe post-op check-ins continuing months after surgery, while The Aesthetics Boutique's loyalty pattern is built around repeat non-surgical visits over years rather than surgical aftercare.
- Track record and consistency. The Aesthetics Boutique posts the higher composite score and rating (94.5 and 5.0 from 527 reviews) versus New Age's 92 and 4.9 from 199 reviews, reflecting a longer, more consistent run of non-surgical results.
Side by side
- Google rating
- The Aesthetics Boutique: 5 (527 reviews)
- New Age Medical Aesthetics & Plastic Surgery: 4.9 (199 reviews)
- Services
- The Aesthetics Boutique: non surgical cosmetic, facial plastic surgery, body contouring, breast augmentation
- New Age Medical Aesthetics & Plastic Surgery: breast augmentation, body contouring, plastic surgery clinic, facial plastic surgery
- Best for
- The Aesthetics Boutique: Non-surgical facial rejuvenation (injectables, skin treatments, laser)
- New Age Medical Aesthetics & Plastic Surgery: Actual facial surgery (surgical procedures, chin work) plus non-surgical add-ons
- Named specialists
- The Aesthetics Boutique: Ashlynn and Charley, injectables and skin treatments
- New Age Medical Aesthetics & Plastic Surgery: Dr. Ian MacArthur (surgery) and Nurse Courtney (injectables, IPL, microneedling, Botox)
- OHIP acceptance
- The Aesthetics Boutique: Not mentioned
- New Age Medical Aesthetics & Plastic Surgery: Accepted for some procedures
- Verification
- The Aesthetics Boutique: Google-verified
- New Age Medical Aesthetics & Plastic Surgery: Google-verified
- Composite score
- The Aesthetics Boutique: 95
- New Age Medical Aesthetics & Plastic Surgery: 92
Within 3 points of each other, so treat them as effectively tied on overall quality. The choice below is about fit, not the score.
What reviewers say
The Aesthetics Boutique
Reviewers consistently credit Ashlynn and her team for building trust through honesty about what treatments are truly needed, never pushing unnecessary services. Every result praised is described as natural and refined rather than overdone, with clients reporting restored confidence in their appearance.
The boutique itself earns praise for cleanliness, warm decor, and professional atmosphere. Clients mention returning year after year (some for 6+ years), and one reviewer attended an open house event with crowds from across the Greater Toronto Area. Staff are named by clients-Ashlynn and Charley-with both noted for patience and skill across injectables, skin treatments, and laser work.
New Age Medical Aesthetics & Plastic Surgery
Dr. MacArthur and his team deliver surgical and non-surgical results that consistently exceed expectations, backed by genuine follow-up care that extends months after treatment. Nurse Courtney's expertise in injectables and laser treatments, combined with personalized skincare planning and zero-pressure consultations, makes this clinic stand out for people wanting to feel heard and informed, not rushed.
The clinic accepts OHIP patients for some procedures and operates across facial surgery, breast work, body contouring, and laser rejuvenation. Staff names surface repeatedly in praise: Dr. Ian MacArthur for surgery and chin work, and Courtney for non-surgical treatments, IPL, microneedling, and Botox. Reviewers consistently note that post-op check-ins happen months later.
Need help deciding?
Describe what you're looking for and get responses from plastic surgeon in Ontario offering consultations in your region.
Enquiries submitted through our contact forms may be shared with partner providers who can do the work, and we may receive a referral fee. Our rankings and scores are based on our published method only, separate from any referral fees we earn.
FAQ
- Which clinic actually performs facial surgery?
- New Age Medical Aesthetics & Plastic Surgery is the one with a named surgeon, Dr. Ian MacArthur, reviewers credit for facial surgery and chin work. The Aesthetics Boutique's reviews describe injectables, skin treatments, and laser work rather than surgical procedures.
- Does either clinic accept OHIP?
- New Age Medical Aesthetics & Plastic Surgery accepts OHIP for some procedures. No OHIP coverage is mentioned for The Aesthetics Boutique.
- Which has the stronger track record on paper?
- The Aesthetics Boutique has the higher composite score (94.5 vs 92) and a 5.0 rating from 527 reviews, compared to New Age's 4.9 from 199 reviews.
- What does aftercare look like at each?
- New Age reviewers describe post-op check-ins continuing months after surgery. The Aesthetics Boutique's pattern is repeat non-surgical visits over years rather than surgical follow-up.